What is Lumber Grade?
Lumber grading is a quality control system that sorts wood into categories based on visual appearance and structural characteristics. Higher grades command premium prices; lower grades are used for applications where appearance doesn't matter.
Grading Systems
Hardwood Lumber (FAS System)
FAS (Firsts and Seconds) - HIGHEST GRADE:
- 83% clear (defect-free) on worst face
- Minimum board size: 6" wide × 8' long
- Use: Fine furniture, cabinetry, musical instruments
- Costa Rican example: Premium teak, mahogany
Select:
- 83% clear on best face only
- Slightly smaller boards allowed
- Use: Furniture with one good face
- One face shows, one hidden
No. 1 Common:
- 66% clear on worst face
- Smaller clear areas acceptable
- Use: Furniture parts, flooring
- More affordable than FAS
No. 2 Common:
- 50% clear on worst face
- Significant defects present
- Use: Rustic furniture, paint-grade work
- Economy grade
No. 3 Common (Below Grade):
- Less than 50% clear
- Heavy defects, many knots
- Use: Pallets, crating, utility purposes
- Cheapest grade
Softwood Lumber (Different System)
Not common in Costa Rica, but for reference:
- Select grades: B&BTR (Best), C Select, D Select
- Common grades: No. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
What Graders Look For
Defects That Lower Grade
Natural Characteristics:
- Knots: Size, type (sound vs loose), location, frequency
- Pitch pockets: Resin accumulations
- Mineral streaks: Discoloration from minerals
- Wane: Bark edge or missing wood on board edge
- Shake: Grain separation along growth rings
- Insect damage: Beetle holes, powder post beetles
Processing Defects:
- Checks and splits: Cracks from drying
- Warp: Cup, bow, twist, crook
- Skip: Saw missed section
- Torn grain: Rough, fuzzy surface
- Stain: Discoloration from fungi (not rot)
Measurements:
- Board dimensions: Wider and longer = higher grade possible
- Clear wood percentage: Amount with no defects
- Defect size: Larger defects lower grade more
Costa Rican Hardwood Grading
Premium Species
Teca (Teak) - Tectona grandis:
- Plantation teak often grades lower than natural forest
- Young plantation (12-15 years): Mostly No. 1-2 Common
- Old plantation (25+ years): Can achieve FAS
- Natural forest teak: Consistently FAS-Select
Caoba (Mahogany) - Swietenia macrophylla:
- Large, old-growth trees: FAS grade common
- CITES restrictions limit availability
- Highly valued for furniture and boatbuilding
- Even No. 1 Common sells at premium
Cocobolo (Rosewood) - Dalbergia retusa:
- Small logs limit grade potential
- Even Select grade commands high prices
- Used in small pieces (knife handles, jewelry)
- Grading less relevant due to high overall value
Common Native Timbers
Laurel (Cordia alliodora):
- Wide range of grades produced
- Fast-grown plantation: More knots, lower grades
- Natural forest: Higher FAS percentage
- Very popular for local furniture
Pochote (Pachira quinata):
- Lightweight, even-grained
- Produces good percentages of Select-FAS
- Machines cleanly with minimal defects
Melina (Gmelina arborea):
- Plantation species, 8-10 year rotation
- Mostly No. 2-3 Common grades
- Many knots from fast growth
- Used for utility lumber, pallets
Practical Implications
For Buyers
Furniture Projects:
- Visible parts: Buy FAS or Select
- Hidden parts: No. 1 Common saves money
- Paint grade: No. 2 Common acceptable
- Practice projects: No. 3 Common for learning
Construction:
- Framing: Common grades sufficient
- Flooring: No. 1 Common minimum
- Trim: Select or FAS recommended
- Decking: No. 2 Common adequate if treated
For Sellers
Maximizing Value:
- Proper drying reduces checking/warp
- Careful sawing reduces skip and tear-out
- Grading before sale ensures fair price
- Higher grades can sell for 3-5x lower grades
Grading Certification
Standards Bodies
- NHLA: National Hardwood Lumber Association (US standard)
- Costa Rican mills: Often use adapted NHLA rules
- Export market: Requires certified grading
- Domestic market: More informal, buyer inspection
Why It Matters
Understanding lumber grades helps with:
- Purchasing decisions: Buy appropriate quality
- Cost savings: Don't overpay for grade you don't need
- Project planning: Estimate material costs accurately
- Quality expectations: Know what you're getting
- Selling timber: Get fair market value
- Sustainability: Lower grades reduce waste (use whole tree)